Pin beside ours

Ten of the pins you rated highest, each recreated closely with Banana Joe Games material. On the left is your pin, on the right ours. Rate the one on the right: one to five stars, or ✕. A note on what is still off helps most.

What to know

• One visual code for all ten: Anton and Barlow, banana yellow, black and cream, the banana halftone. Nothing is reserved for one game.
• A critic set each one beside its pin and sent it back until it held. Seven passed; r07, r08 and r09 stayed a notch below, and each says what still separates it under its caption.
• All ten are editable frames in the Figma file, on the page "Round 3 · Recreations (step 1)", each beside its pin.
• These follow someone else's composition. They are studies to find the language; before one is posted we look again at how far it stands from its source.